“If you don’t stop running in the store, you’ll get a time out when we get home.” “If you are really good in here, you’ll get a treat at the check out aisle.” If you ever found yourself trying these “motivating” statements, I’m sure you may just roll your eyes and realize how many times they don’t work. When we think about these things from the child’s perspective you can start to see why.
Let’s take the threat. When children receive a threat, they take a moment to think about the threat. They wonder how serious a threat it is. They wonder whether the parent will carry out the threat. They know from experience that not all threats are carried out. Quickly they decide that the chance is worth taking and they “cross over the line”. A threat is almost like you are asking your child to cross the line. Our only recourse to them is to increase our threat. At some point, our child may give in – if our threat is great enough. But threatening our kids into submission is a negative, time-consuming, and exhausting process for a parent. It just isn’t worth it.
The converse to threats is bribes. “If you are really good, you can get some M&M’s.” Just what does the parent mean by “good” is always the question. Inevitably, at the end of the required time, the child thinks he or she was good and deserves the prize. Meanwhile, your child has pushed you to the point of a few more gray hairs and you do not feel like giving the bribe.
Parents and children do better when bribes and threats aren’t used. It is much better to think of rewards and consequences. These should come as immediate consequences to your child’s behavior. “You were so patient when you waited for me, you deserve a reward.” The reward comes as a result of an already performed positive behavior. Your child will be more likely to perform that behavior again. Remember, they don’t need to know that rewards are coming. They get them when you acknowledge their behavior. Rewards can be just praise or perhaps a bragging story telling to your spouse. This attention is a positive reward. Or rewards can be just a time spent together doing what they want. Of course, other rewards are appropriate at times as well.
A consequence should be an immediate response to an unwanted behavior. “You were running in the store so now you need to hold my hand.” Threats prolong the games played between parent and child. A consequence ends the behavior usually by restricting them from a freedom.
Both rewards and consequence should be appropriate for the age of the child and the degree of the action. Over-rewarding leads to spoiling and severe consequences are mean to children. All parents have to come to a happy medium in their rewards and consequences. If you do, your child will learn a great deal from you without threats and bribes.